Not-for-Profit and Charity Experts. Discounted flat fees.
We have offices Australia wide and provide consultations from
9am - 10:30 pm AEST Monday to Saturday.
SYDNEY (02) 9375 2209
BRISBANE (07) 3181 4340
PERTH (08) 9288 1746
AFTER HOURS +61 480 897 412
DISCLAIMER: This information is not and is not to be considered or used as legal, financial, governance or taxation advice and is general in nature. While we present this publicly available information in a clear and concise manner, it may become outdated or inaccurate. Information provided is not to be classified as an opinion and/or advice. You are obligated to check the latest information and regulatory requirements with the appropriate Australian Government and State regulatory authorities. Non Profit Specialists take no responsibility for any inaccuracies and refuse any and all responsibility and liability for decisions you make based on publicly available information republished on our website.
The core distinction
Every charity is a not-for-profit. Most not-for-profits are not charities.
A charity is a narrower legal status sitting inside the broader NFP category — an organisation only reaches charity status if it clears three additional tests that a plain not-for-profit doesn’t have to meet.
In one line: a not-for-profit only has to not distribute profit to its members. A charity has to actually exist for a recognised charitable purpose and benefit the public rather than just its own members.
The test
The three-part test
Under the Charities Act 2013 (Cth), an organisation is only eligible to register as a charity with the ACNC if it passes all three of the following.
1. Purpose — does it fit one of the 12 recognised charitable purposes under s 12 (advancing health, education, religion, culture, the environment, relieving poverty, preventing animal suffering, and so on)?
2. Public benefit — under s 6, does the benefit go to the public or a genuine section of it, or mainly to the organisation’s own members (mutual benefit)?
3. No disqualifying purpose — under s 11, it isn’t engaged in unlawful activity, and it isn’t set up primarily to promote or oppose a political party or candidate.
Source
Charities Act 2013 (Cth) ss 6, 11, 12; Australian Charities and Not-for-profits Commission Act 2012 (Cth)
Pass all three
Eligible to register as a charity with the ACNC.
Fail any one
Still a completely legitimate not-for-profit — it just stays outside the ACNC system, without ACNC-specific obligations, but also without ACNC-specific benefits like Deductible Gift Recipient (DGR) eligibility in most cases.
The test that trips people up most
Public benefit vs mutual benefit
The distinction that catches most organisations out is public benefit versus mutual (or private) benefit. Mutual benefit means using the organisation’s resources for its own members, or a closed group connected to it. An entity that exists mainly for that purpose cannot be a charity, no matter how worthwhile its activities feel.
Public benefit
If the benefit flows to anyone in the relevant need or category — patients, students at a public school, the environment, animals, the poor — that’s public benefit. If the purpose also matches one of the 12 categories, it’s charity-eligible.
Mutual / private benefit
If the benefit flows mainly to the people who joined and pay for it — club members, industry association members, a company’s own employees — that’s mutual or private benefit, and no amount of good intent turns it into a charity.
This is why the ACNC will treat a scholarship fund open only to one company’s employees’ children as a closed class (private benefit), even though ‘funding education’ sounds charitable on its face.
Source
ACNC — Charitable purpose; Charities Act 2013 (Cth) s 6
Real-world examples
Case studies — where organisations land, and why
The same three-part test, applied to eleven organisations you’d recognise.
Organisation | Structure | Charity? | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
A homelessness charity providing shelter and support to anyone in need | Company limited by guarantee | Charity | Purpose = relieving poverty/advancing social welfare; benefit flows to any member of the public who needs it — an open class, not a closed one. Often also registers as a Public Benevolent Institution subtype. |
A scholarship fund open only to the children of one company’s employees | Trust | Not a charity | A ‘closed class’ of beneficiaries — private benefit to a defined group, not public benefit — even though ‘funding education’ sounds charitable on its face. |
An organisation set up mainly to campaign for a political candidate or party | Any structure | Cannot be a charity | Disqualifying purpose under s 11 of the Charities Act 2013 (Cth) — an automatic bar, not a balancing test, even if some other activities look charitable. |
A trade union | Registered organisation (Fair Work Act, not the ACNC) | Not a charity | Purpose = advancing the interests of a specific group of employees — sectional/mutual benefit, and unions sit under different legislation entirely. |
Private golf or bowls club | Incorporated association | Not a charity | Purpose = providing facilities/services to paying members. Classic mutual benefit — no broader public benefit even if the clubhouse hosts occasional community events. |
Regional Chamber of Commerce / industry association | Incorporated association or CLG | Not a charity | Purpose = advancing the commercial interests of member businesses — mutual benefit to a defined, closed group, even if the association does genuinely good work. |
Suburban football/netball club | Incorporated association | Not a charity | Purpose = providing sport and recreation to its own members. Sport isn’t itself one of the 12 charitable categories, and the benefit is mutual, not public. Can still self-assess income tax exemption under the ATO’s sporting-club category. |
A school Parents & Citizens Association | Incorporated association | Usually a charity | Purpose = advancing education at a public school; even though it’s parent-driven, the benefit flows to students and the school community broadly, not to the parents personally. |
A local Landcare group | Incorporated association | Charity | Purpose = advancing the natural environment; benefit flows to the whole community/environment, not just members. |
RSPCA | Incorporated association / CLG | Charity | Purpose = advancing health / relieving suffering (charitable purpose); benefit flows to the entire community; no disqualifying purpose. |
Cancer Council | Company limited by guarantee | Charity | Purpose = preventing/relieving the suffering of animals — one of the 12 named charitable purposes directly. |
The takeaway
The pattern to take away
The recurring question is always: who is the benefit actually for?
Benefit to the public or an open class in need
Anyone who is sick, any student at a public school, the environment generally, anyone who is homeless — public benefit, charity-eligible if the purpose also fits one of the 12 categories.
Benefit mainly to the people who joined and pay for it
Club members, industry association members, a closed employee group — mutual or private benefit, not charity-eligible, however good the work is.
This is also why the same activity can sit on either side of the line depending on framing. A club that exists to give its paying members somewhere to play sport stays a non-charitable NFP. A program specifically set up to advance the health or education of disadvantaged children through sport, open to the relevant public, can clear the charitable-purpose bar.
General information: for general questions about charity registration or ACNC requirements, you can contact the ACNC directly on 13 22 62.
We’ve worked with hundreds of non-profits and charities across every state of Australia — whichever path fits your organisation, we can guide your board through it.
Book a free consult
If you’re interested in assistance to set up a charity or a non-profit organisation, please contact us below. We offer free consultations, and you can discuss with one of our experts how we can assist you in setting up and establishing your organisation.
Fill out the form and then schedule your free consultation at your preferred time and day. We offer extended consultation hours from 9 am to 10 pm Australian Eastern Standard Time, Monday to Saturday.
Sources
Legislation
-
Charities Act 2013 (Cth) — ss 5, 6, 11, 12
-
Australian Charities and Not-for-profits Commission Act 2012 (Cth)
-
Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) — registered organisations (trade unions) sit outside the ACNC system
ACNC (acnc.gov.au)
-
Charitable purpose
-
Legal structure
Legislation current at legislation.gov.au and austlii.edu.au. This document is general information for orientation purposes.